As a female and avid music listener I felt it was high time I jumped up and started complaining about both females and music. I am going to focus this grandma style rant on two subjects: Lana Del Rey and MIA. I know, I know, how creative, a blog post about two living memes. However, I feel that these two women accurately illustrate some overarching and seriously irritating points about female music culture.
First off, Lana Del Rey. I first saw her on Pitchfork. My reaction was pretty basic, "she's pretty, her lips look painful, how can she sing with such painful lips?" Then I watched her video and thought, "oh, she can't sing, probably because of her painful lips." Then I hopped over to HRO. They quickly jumped on the fact that she isn't really named LDR and that her lips used to be unpuffy. Not really a huge surprise.
What irked me most was the fact that she was a rich white girl who changed her name to Lana Del Rey, and billed herself as a "gansta Nancy Sinatra," and Pitchfork mentioned her trailer park aesthetic. As white trash this made me a little McMad. I was upset that some focus group took a girl whose dad made millions and produced a super pretty Best Coast. I was also irked that here we have this rich white girl and she uses a Hispanic name and wears giant gold jewelry, and big fake nails like a homegirl.
So, here we have some frankenstein monster of Best Coast and Gwen Stefani, and the worst part is... they (record executives) didn't take the time to each her to sing or preform. I love me some trashy pop, Britney Spear's "Toxic" is delicious. I also know that Britney is manufactured down to the slightest wink, but I am okay with that because she and the company did it well.
| Indie throw back chick not exuding sexuality |
| Add edgy hot rock edge |
| Sum less than its parts |
Furthermore, I think that Kirsten Wiig's impersonation (while funny) illustrated that most people are criticizing LDR for the wrong reasons. The fact that she is weird is not offensive, I love weird, strange, bizarre the whole gamete. What is offensive is her entire lack feminist slant. Her songs hinge on making a male figure happy. Her entire persona was fashioned to give a large male hipster crowd a boner, while telling the young female hipster that being submissive is preferred. Finally, I take um bridge with her comparison with Nancy Sinatra. This is Nancy Sinatra....

I believe she is saying, "these boot were made for walking." Translated, if you don't stop playing your fucking video games I am outta here. The manufactured quality of LDR seems vaguely familiar now that I think about it... wait....

Yup... this makes sense.... LDR is a fembot minus the artillery. Making her a slightly more functional blow up doll which croons.
Now on to part B, or part 2, this has been a long post and I forget what I am talking about. Anyway. MIA has had a pretty big last couple of weeks. She dropped an awesome music video, was in the slightly less awesome Madonna music video, and oh right she preformed at the SuperBowl. Now when I first heard about her playing the SuperBowl I rolled my eyes. I mean playing the biggest event for the lowest denomination of America... The very people you claim to despise? But then she righted the assumptions. MIA has always had the tack and the political zealotry of a 12 year old, so I am not sure why anyone is surprised. I for one was much more distracted by the writhing of the scanitily clad back up dancers to even notice being flipped off.
Why weren't the good, morally upstanding SuperBowl viewers loosing there shit over a provacative dance? Well I have a couple of theories. First off, the dancer is submissive and doing her gesture to please the viewer. The dancer is on her back, a good place for any lady. Second, MIA's gesture is just about the opposite. She is leaning forward, being aggressive, telling us she doesn't give a shit. Mostly though she isn't doing this for our entertainment and that is really what is offensive (not to mention that it is a minority woman not entertaining us).
Really that is what separates MIA and LDR, the desire to entertain. Both women are living meme machines and crave internet attention. The difference is the manner in which both women go through to get the attention. LDR stays on the path of the back up dancer: pretty, submissive, meant purely to reaffirm existing values about women. MIA, while immature and oft misinformed, is at least trying to form an alternate opinion of women. Her Bad Girls music video address the issue of Saudi women not being able to drive, whether she really has any depth to this argument is a moot point. She is at least taking steps away from a formulated image of women. And I think that is why I can so easily accept MIA, Gwen Stefani, and Best Coast, they give an alteration image of women, where as LDR gives me what a male executive expects.
Pictures from:
http://forums.superherohype.com/showthread.php?t=367909
http://thefashionreview.wordpress.com/2009/04/09/our-love-is-rock-steady/
http://www.last.fm/music/Best+Coast/+images/42277125
http://insidetv.ew.com/2012/02/05/middle-finger-super-bowl-photo/
x



























